StoreAudit vs Shopify Agency
AI-powered automated audit vs full-service agency engagement
What is Shopify Agency?
Shopify agencies like cro.media, Eastside Co, and boutique Shopify consultancies offer manual store audits as part of their service offerings. Prices range from $299 for a basic audit to $1,500-$2,000+ for premium agency engagements. Delivery takes 1-3 weeks and typically includes a PDF report — but no re-audit, no tracking, and no monthly monitoring.
Feature-by-Feature Comparison
| Feature | StoreAudit | Shopify Agency |
|---|---|---|
| Price per audit | $29/mo (unlimited audits) | $299-$2,000+ per audit |
| Turnaround | Under 60 seconds | 1-3 weeks |
| Re-audits | Unlimited monthly (Pro) | Pay again each time |
| Historical tracking | Yes — score history + delta | No |
| Competitor comparison | Yes | Rare; add-on cost |
| AI Visibility Score | Yes | No agency offers this |
| Consistency | Identical methodology every audit | Varies by analyst |
| Human strategy | AI recommendations (not human) | Yes — personalized |
| Implementation help | Fix steps included; you implement | Can implement for you |
| Annual cost | $348/year (Pro) | $1,500-$10,000+/year |
StoreAudit Strengths
- ✓$29/mo vs $299-2,000/audit — saves 90-98% on audit costs
- ✓Instant results — no waiting weeks for a report
- ✓Unlimited audits on Pro — run after every major change
- ✓AI Visibility Score: brand new dimension no agency offers
Shopify Agency Strengths
- ✓Human expertise catches nuanced UX and brand issues automated tools miss
- ✓Strategic business advice beyond technical fixes
- ✓Agencies can implement fixes for you — not just diagnose
Shopify Agency Limitations
- ✗$299-$2,000 per audit — 10-70x more expensive per audit
- ✗1-3 week turnaround vs 60 seconds
- ✗No ongoing monitoring or re-audits included
- ✗Quality varies widely between agencies and analysts
Our Honest Take
Run StoreAudit first to get an instant, objective baseline. After 10 minutes you will know exactly which issues are critical and which are easy wins. If specific issues require expert Shopify Liquid development or custom strategy, hire an agency for those targeted tasks. Most merchants save thousands annually by using StoreAudit for diagnosis.
Ready to see what's broken?
Get your full 6-category audit in under 60 seconds.
Scan My Store Free